2nd opinions
Warning: The messages in this forum are the personal views and opinions of individuals. NEVER act on any advice or opinion posted in this forum without FIRST checking with your personal physician! Mood Tracker Web Media, LLC is not obligated to check forum postings for accuracy nor does it endorse the opinions of any person using the forum.
February 10, 2009 - 5:57 pm
Ive been seeing my pdoc for 5 years now. I get my hopes up times and again only to crash and bur,n The only good thing that came out of this experience is that I am learning to live with depression and have been able to keep my job,I used to look forward to the future with optimism amd now somretimes this not there, I cannot think of anything scarier than a purposelss exist ence ,ifthere is one pleasedon't tell me. There has been talk of electrconvulsive therapy. 2. nd, any opinions all are welcome Help JD
Current medications as of 02-10-2009
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Abilify, 2mg. once a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Cymbalta, 120mg. once a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Flomax, 0.4mg. once a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Lithium, 300mg. 2 times a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Lyrica, 75mg. 3 times a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Prestiq, 100mg. once a day |
| 01-08-2009 - Present: | Wellbutrin XL, 300mg. once daily |
Ive been seeing my pdoc for 5 years now. I get my hopes up times and again only to crash and bur,n The only good thing that came out of this experience is that I am learning to live with depression and have been able to keep my job,I used to look forward to the future with optimism amd now somretimes this not there, I cannot think of anything scarier than a purposelss exist ence ,ifthere is one pleasedon't tell me. There has been talk of electrconvulsive therapy. 2. nd, any opinions all are welcome Help JD
Current medications as of 02-10-2009
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Abilify, 2mg. once a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Cymbalta, 120mg. once a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Flomax, 0.4mg. once a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Lithium, 300mg. 2 times a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Lyrica, 75mg. 3 times a day |
| 12-31-2008 - Present: | Prestiq, 100mg. once a day |
| 01-08-2009 - Present: | Wellbutrin XL, 300mg. once daily |
February 15, 2009 - 10:21 pm
Total Posts: 15
Joined: 11-18-2008
Joined: 11-18-2008
I think getting a second opinion from another psychiatrist is always a good idea. I saw the same pdoc for about 4 years, a ton of med changes, and things just weren't getting better. So I went to get a second opinion from another pdoc to basically ask if they agreed with my current pdoc's methods of treatment or if they had any better ideas. It's nice to either have confirmation that your doc is doing what other doctors would do, or find out if someone has some fresh ideas. I eventually changed pdoc's and feel like the one I have now really listens to me and makes adjustments based on what I tell him--rather than putting all of his faith into the medications. In my experience, some pdocs are so sure that certain meds work that they'll continue to push them despite the fact that you're not getting better--it seems they believe in the power of the medication more than they believe what you're telling them about lack of improvement in your mood. Just my opinion though. I think it's important to find a pdoc you trust, one who listens, and one who will work with you on a treatment plan (with your input) to find something that works for you.
I think getting a second opinion from another psychiatrist is always a good idea. I saw the same pdoc for about 4 years, a ton of med changes, and things just weren't getting better. So I went to get a second opinion from another pdoc to basically ask if they agreed with my current pdoc's methods of treatment or if they had any better ideas. It's nice to either have confirmation that your doc is doing what other doctors would do, or find out if someone has some fresh ideas. I eventually changed pdoc's and feel like the one I have now really listens to me and makes adjustments based on what I tell him--rather than putting all of his faith into the medications. In my experience, some pdocs are so sure that certain meds work that they'll continue to push them despite the fact that you're not getting better--it seems they believe in the power of the medication more than they believe what you're telling them about lack of improvement in your mood. Just my opinion though. I think it's important to find a pdoc you trust, one who listens, and one who will work with you on a treatment plan (with your input) to find something that works for you.
February 16, 2009 - 12:08 pm
Total Posts: 7
Joined: 12-31-2008
Joined: 12-31-2008
to soandso,
Your input is well thought out and reasonable. (Just what I need) . Truthfully I have been thinking about this, but sometimes it is hard to get up the nerve to do this. It sounds like you have had a sucessful experience. This is just the nudge I need ,I have the names of Pdocs already, I need action, after all it just a phone call and then follow instructions. Thank you much Johnd
Your input is well thought out and reasonable. (Just what I need) . Truthfully I have been thinking about this, but sometimes it is hard to get up the nerve to do this. It sounds like you have had a sucessful experience. This is just the nudge I need ,I have the names of Pdocs already, I need action, after all it just a phone call and then follow instructions. Thank you much Johnd
to soandso,
Your input is well thought out and reasonable. (Just what I need) . Truthfully I have been thinking about this, but sometimes it is hard to get up the nerve to do this. It sounds like you have had a sucessful experience. This is just the nudge I need ,I have the names of Pdocs already, I need action, after all it just a phone call and then follow instructions. Thank you much Johnd
Your input is well thought out and reasonable. (Just what I need) . Truthfully I have been thinking about this, but sometimes it is hard to get up the nerve to do this. It sounds like you have had a sucessful experience. This is just the nudge I need ,I have the names of Pdocs already, I need action, after all it just a phone call and then follow instructions. Thank you much Johnd
February 16, 2009 - 12:18 pm
Total Posts: 146
Joined: 01-04-2009
Joined: 01-04-2009
Yes, Yes--I vote for second opinions on just about any medical issue--docs are people too and anyone can make a mistake or get stuck in a rut and not really hear you.
Another good thing to look for, do the people at your care place work as a team? I know my pdoc listens to input from my talk therapy person and it has helped a lot with getting me diagnosed correctly.
Another good thing to look for, do the people at your care place work as a team? I know my pdoc listens to input from my talk therapy person and it has helped a lot with getting me diagnosed correctly.
Yes, Yes--I vote for second opinions on just about any medical issue--docs are people too and anyone can make a mistake or get stuck in a rut and not really hear you.
Another good thing to look for, do the people at your care place work as a team? I know my pdoc listens to input from my talk therapy person and it has helped a lot with getting me diagnosed correctly.
Another good thing to look for, do the people at your care place work as a team? I know my pdoc listens to input from my talk therapy person and it has helped a lot with getting me diagnosed correctly.
Joined: 12-31-2008